An Interview with Nehaa Patil..
Dear All: Following the series of interviews on my blog of young, aspiring, independent politicians, I am pleased to carry below an interview with Nehaa Patil, Lok Sabha candidate from Bengaluru North constituency. Many of you may have already joined Nehaa’s campaign page on facebook…She now also has a website where you can join as a volunteer, contribute and express your support. Nehaa’s initiative is commendable and deserves full support. She – and others like her – are showing the way that change can come to India..
All we need are a few young women and men of integrity who are passionate about India and clear that change has to come via the democratic process by providing an alternative in terms of leadership to the poor choices we have… Please do all you can to support her in this endeavour…We need many many more like her…Read on…
** Interview with Nehaa S Patil, LokSabha candidate from Bengaluru North ***
What prompted you to jump into active politics?
I am a woman with the drive and determination to help myself, my family, my community as well as contribute to the progress of the nation. The society in which I live has played a great role in providing me all the facilities and for making me what I am today. I am grateful to my society & this gratitude has created a hunger in me to serve the people. I have been thinking for many years to join active politics and I have finally joined it, no matter what, now is the time to serve the people and contribute to the progress of the nation. I have joined active politics because I believe that politics is that one field which provides an opportunity to help the people of my constituency as individuals with direct assistance, and also help them as a member of a larger group by supporting policies that contribute to their joint well being.  I intend to represent the people of Bangalore North Constituency as MP not only to take care of the people’s needs but also to develop an effective relationship with my constituency people that contributes to democracy by strengthening the people’s connection with their government, and by providing “real life” assessments of how government programs are actually working on the ground.
What are the biggest hurdles/challenges you are facing?
The biggest challenges that I am facing are
- How to devise effective and genuine communication strategies to connect and build trust with my constituency people at an affordable cost; and
- How to raise funds from the general public to meet my campaign expenses
What are the critical ingredients that will make this campaign a success?
I feel that running a political campaign is one of the most challenging and exhausting activities. The critical ingredients that can make campaign a success in this modern political age are:
- Using technology as a backbone of the campaign to make our campaign effort much easier.
- Having the right persons to hold three key positions namely treasurer, fund raiser, and campaign manager, in the campaign.
- A carefully formulated campaign budget calculated on the basis of the vote target- the number of votes needed to win.
- Formulating the right strategy and message for the campaign that reflects my personal beliefs and makes people comfortable with it.
- Running the day-to-day campaign with this sound planning and revising the same based on changed circumstances.
What is your position on campaign finance? What are your views on corruption in elections/ vote-rigging?
I believe that as a candidate for MP from Bangalore North Constituency, I should communicate with each potential voter at least six times. This voter contact cannot happen without spending. In addition, I need to spend on fund raising, staff, and other overheads. Â Wherefore, without campaign finance, there are no chances of running a successful campaign. On the one hand, political candidates are left on their own to raise funds to meet their campaign expenses though candidates from political parties receive some financial support from their respective political parties. On the other hand, political parties are dependent on the contributions from special interest groups. Lack of proper campaign finance has encouraged only those who have enough money, to contest elections.
To have clean elections, we need to spend clean money. Election reforms in this aspect are the need of the hour. Till then, political candidates like me have to rely on grass root supporters and generous public for contributions to meet campaign expenses. General public should get into the giving mood to contribute to the campaign funds of deserving candidates. Â Using money to buy votes, spending money beyond the limit fixed by the election commission, vote-rigging and other election related offences are not new in India. There are effective laws to prevent them but election commission requires a strong commitment and infrastructure to implement them to the fullest extent. Even people can play a vital role in having free and fair elections.
What is the single biggest problem in Indian politics today? Is it Corruption? Is it Criminalization? Is it lack of competence? Is it fragmentation of electoral base – along casteist, religious, regional lines? Is it something else?
The single biggest problem in Indian Politics today is voting in ignorance or with indifference. People should realize that their one vote could doom this country to failure, or it can help this country flourish for years to come. Everything will fall in line the day people realize the importance of their vote and use it to support issue-based politics.
What are your views on “criminalization” of politics and views on banning people with criminal convictions from standing for elections?
The evil of criminalization of politics needs to be addressed on top priority because it destroys the very foundations of our democracy. Â One the one hand, electoral reforms is the need of the hour to bar people with criminal convictions from contesting elections. On the other hand, the people should wake up at once and force the political parties to field good people so that people facing serious criminal charges and undergoing trial are also not given ticket to contest elections.
What is your stance towards economic reforms?
It is a known fact that India was exposed to economic reforms in 1991. India’s economic performance in the post-reforms period has many positive features. India’s economic reforms have been piecemeal and incremental, giving the casual observer the impression that nothing has been happening. If one takes the totality of reforms over the last two decades however, the change is unmistakable. We still have a long way to go. Lack of sufficient progress in land, labour and infrastructure reforms is actually holding back growth. Economic reforms needs to be fine tuned to achieve the objective of inclusive growth that helps the poor reap a fair share of the growth dividend.
What are your views on reservations in education, jobs, promotions, and private sector and also your views on reservations on the basis of caste, religion, socio-economic measures?
Those who enjoy the benefits of reservation want it to be continued and those who do not, want it to be discontinued. It is very essential for us to understand why reservations were provided in India in the first place. It was meant to improve the well being of perceived backward and underrepresented communities in India. The easy way to provide reservations then was to use caste as a base because caste was a vital reason for a person to be educationally, socially, and economically backward. However the creamy layer of people belonging to those castes and communities is enjoying all the benefits of reservations and others from those castes and communities remained where they were before and after independence. The reservation policy needs to be fine tuned so that the benefits of reservations reach those who are in real need. It is important to note that neither the ruling coalition nor the opposition oppose reservations. It is the People who believe in development, competency, equality and unity who want reservations to be removed. It is an issue that needs to be tackled carefully by taking ground reality into consideration.  However, I am of the opinion that the best solution would not be to remove reservations, but to amend the Constitution to provide reservation for the poor belonging to all castes.
What is your position with regards to hot-pursuit across the border?
It is quite natural that any sovereign country including India will never allow any foreign boots to intrude on its soil. I am not in favour of ‘Hot Pursuit’ as it may be misinterpreted as a provocation that could spark wider wars or lend greater legitimacy to nations that launch preemptive strikes under the legal mantle of “anticipatory self-defense.†However there is nothing wrong in utilizing the same when sanctioned by the UN Security Council because such sanction reflects the backing of international community for such a measure.
What are your views on sanctions against Pakistan?
I am not for any sanctions imposed on a nation by a single nation because the nation that faces sanctions can always claim that such sanctions imposed are illegal and also because other nations react negatively or positively to such sanctions with their self interest in mind. I am for the international sanctions, backed by the UN, on Pakistan in case any act of Pakistan is a threat to peace.
What are your views on taxes – should there be an infrastructure tax? How about direct taxes and indirect taxes?
Tax Reforms are the need of the hour. Through Tax Reforms, India needs to position itself as a common free flowing market to truly leverage its stand as a fast growing economy in the global platform and thereby improving its competitiveness.
The Direct Taxes Code (DTC) is being brought to replace the existing Income Tax Act, 1961. I anticipate the impact of Direct Taxes Code as largely positive even though many of the provisions of the Income Tax Act will be part of the Direct Tax Code.
One of the most important reforms needed in the indirect tax system is to have a coordinated consumption tax system for the country. Such a system is necessary to ensure fair distribution of the tax burden among different sectors and between goods and services, to improve revenue productivity, to minimize relative price distortions, and above all, to ensure a common market in the country without placing impediments on the movement of factors and products. The uniform Goods and Services Tax (GST) is an important indirect tax system being brought to replace the existing indirect tax system. Done right, we would be left with only three taxes: the Direct Tax, the GST and the Property tax. This will reduce compliance costs, economic distortions and harassment.
The GST and DTC were anticipated to come into force w.e.f April 1st, 2012. The present Government needs to take effective steps to make GST and DTC a reality.
When there is a measure to remove almost all the existing taxes leaving only three taxes: The Direct Tax, the GST, and the Property Tax, There is no need for levy of separate taxes such as ‘Infrastructure Tax’.
What are your views on the parallel economy: how do you see the problem and how would you deal with it?
Parallel economy is that one insect that eats into the root of a Country’s Robust Economy. Parallel economy ensures that the rich becomes richer through illegal means at the cost of the poor and the middle class. One of the outcomes of parallel economy is generation of black money. While black money which operates within the country can be productive to some extent, what goes overseas is non-productive. I believe in what the Wanchoo Committee concluded: “It is no exaggeration to say that black money is like a cancerous growth in the country’s economy which, if not checked in time, is sure to lead to its ruinationâ€. I am for any measures which are within the purview of national and international laws. In addition, it is necessary to enact legislations that make all transactions transparent, and also to evolve a stringent and deterrent punishment system to discourage people from involving in parallel economic activities.
What is the most important “social” issue facing our country today?
The most important social issue that also has an economic angle facing our country today is ‘Poverty’. With nearly four out of five Indians living in poverty, millions of Indians are caught in a lethal web. The present economic and political policies framed to eradicate poverty amounts to a mere tokenism. The present and future Governments should have a concrete goal with a time frame to reduce poverty with an aim to provide adequate nutrition, clean water, basic sanitation, education, enforced constitutional rights, and basic health care for all.
What is the most important “economic” issue facing us today?
The most important ‘economic’ issue facing our country today is ‘inflation’. Higher the inflation, the higher is the cost of living for the populace. With most of India’s vast population living close to or below the poverty line, inflation acts as a ‘Poor Man’s Tax’. This effect is magnified when food prices rise as food represents more than half of the expenditure of this group. The Government should take immediate measures to bring down the inflation to a rate where it ceases to be a cause of major concern.
*** End of Interview ***
I invite you to ask questions to Nehaa on other issues that you may have an interest in – either by leaving a comment below – or of course on her facebook page. In the meantime, pl consider how you can support and contribute to her campaign. Jai Hind, Jai Bharat!
Related Posts: An Interview with Nisha Singh,
Interview with Deepak Mittal, “Jago Partyâ€
Interview with Ujjwal Banerjee and Interview with Geeta Gokhale, BPD
I am honoured to be interviewed by you Shantanu. I am for a single standard of conduct in both public and private life, and for actions in all endeavors that speak of transparency, accountability and sincerity. Looking forward for support and guidance for people from all walks of life.
Not at all Nehaa…The pleasure was mine…And I wish you the very best in this endeavour…You have chosen the hard way..all the power to you!
What a Breath of fresh air!!! When cynicism is rampant individuals like Nehaa-ji are showing and leading the way by engaging in the political process via elections. It is very inspiring that educated (not just educated but one with an impressive resume) people such as her are considering political representation seriously.
All the best to Nehaa-ji on campaign and elections!!
Few questions to Nehaa S Patil?
1)Is the double ‘a’ in your first name for luck as per numerology?
2)What are your plans to relocate Kashmiri Pandits who are living as refugees in their home land?
3)What are your views on FDI, both retail and aviation?
4)You say “The most important ‘economic’ issue facing our country today is ‘inflation’”. What are your plans to stop imports of oil which accounts for 70% of our import bill, the key component in inflation.
5)How can we curb the sudden explosion of real estate (the most opaque asset sector) in Bangalore that is also leading to excessive population (both human & vehicular) resulting in degradation through pollution?
6)What are your views on conversion and should anti-conversion bill an effective means to curb conversion?
K P Ganesh Ji, My views on your Q’s are as under:-
1) is the double ‘a’ in your first name for luck as per numerology?
Thank you for noticing double ‘A’ in my name. The same is added to my name to match the pronunciation in Kannada.
2) What are your plans to relocate Kashmiri Pandits who are living as refugees in their home land?
I am against any plans to forcibly relocate Kashmiri Pandits because living in Kashmir is their birth right. The reasons are known to everyone including the Union and State Government as to why they are living as refugees in their homeland. The Union and State Governments should take effective measures so as to see that their right to live peacefully in their homeland is protected by all means. Any measures taken through collaborative efforts will yield results. However I am not a competent authority to suggest any measures.
3) What are your views on FDI, both retail and aviation?
FDI in Retail: I had posted a comment on FB campaign page as under:-
“On the one hand, FDI in retail is in the consumer’s best interest to obtain his goods and services at the lowest possible price. On the other hand, it is widely feared that opening the retailing sector to FDI means dislocating millions from their occupation, and pushing a lot of families under the poverty line.
The Government should not forget that it has a responsibility to provide economic security for the citizens of this country.
I believe no will oppose FDI in retail if its theme is “collective well-being must take precedence over individual benefits”.â€
When the Government of India announced the proposal of introduction of FDI in retail, I had a look at the retailers operating in my constituency. In my constituency, a retailer is born out of circumstance rather than choice. Due to lack of good education & economic opportunities, it is almost a natural decision for an individual in my constituency to set up a small shop, depending on his/her means and capital.
I feel there is a need to protect the interests of such small retailers. I did my own research and came to a conclusion that FDI in retail can be introduced after Government taking some steps to prevent the disadvantages that may result from FDI in retail.
I am not opposed to FDI in retail if its theme is “collective well-being must take precedence over individual benefits”. CPAS has made some suggestions which the Govt should address before bringing FDI in retail. I have tried to put some of those suggestions in a nutshell as below
-98% of the retail sector is unorganized. Bring Policies that encourage unorganized sector retailers to migrate to the organised sector.
-Bring suitable lending policies that will enable retailers in the organised and unorganized sectors to expand and improve efficiencies.
-Establish National Commission to study the problems of the retail sector and to evolve policies that will enable it to cope with FDI.
-Prepare a clear set of conditionalities on giant foreign retailers on the procurement of farm produce, domestically manufactured merchandise and imported goods.
-Entry of foreign retail players must be gradual and with social safeguards to gain time to analyze the bad effects of the FDI policy and take corrective measures.
-To address the dislocation issue, it is essential to develop and improve the manufacturing sector.
-Encourage setting up of co-operative stores to procure and stock their consumer goods and commodities from small producers.
-As the prices of vegetables and fruits are not fixed, care should be taken to protect the interest of the producers. Procurement prices for perishable commodities should be fair.
With the above steps, the Government can try to ensure that the domestic and foreign players are approximately on an equal footing and that the domestic traders are not at an especial disadvantage. Thereafter there may be consensus to introduce FDI in retail. I hope to see FDI in retail in the near future.
FDI in aviation: I welcome the Government proposal to allow foreign airlines to acquire a stake of up to 49 per cent in Indian domestic carriers. There is no other viable solution to lift the Indian airline industry from the morass it is in. The Indian domestic carriers are not opposed to this idea. I hope that the proposal goes through.
4) You say “The most important ‘economic’ issue facing our country today is ‘inflation’”. What are your plans to stop imports of oil which accounts for 70% of our import bill, the key component in inflation?
Our nation’s continuing dependence on foreign countries for oil shows that we still rely on fossil fuels for energy requirements. This dependence is going to hurt economy badly. We need to stop relying on fossil fuels. We need to invest in and innovate new energy sources in order to protect our quality of life and prosperity. Request you to have a look at my stand on ‘Energy’ at http://www.nehaaspatil.org/nehaa/issues/energy.php.
I am for launching a concerted national effort with the goal of moving India beyond fossil fuels and inventing the next generation of energy, based on new technologies such as hydrogen or fusion. This aggressive plan may require a huge national investment but would produce millions of new jobs, could dramatically reduce environmental damage, and free us from our dependence on fossil fuels and foreign oil.
Above all, I believe that each generation has a responsibility to wisely use the country’s resources and power so that they can provide the next generation a secure, sustainable country that is stronger than the one they inherited.
5) How can we curb the sudden explosion of real estate (the most opaque asset sector) in Bangalore that is also leading to excessive population (both human & vehicular) resulting in degradation through pollution?
The average house price makes housing non-affordable in Bangalore for the middle class. I am against migration of young people to affordable places because I believe that there can be no future for any community that cannot retain its young people. I am for the introduction of measures to tackle the problems ranging from an increase in Social Housing provision to Stamp Duty exemption for first time buyers. There is also an issue of migration from places outside Bangalore that needs to be tackled without violating their right to movement as provided in our constitution.
As you said, excessive population (both human and vehicular) is resulting in degradation through pollution. Request you to look at my views on ‘Enviornment’ at my website http://www.nehaaspatil.org/nehaa/issues/environment.php. A clean environment and strong conservation programs are very important to me and I am willing to work with anyone for the same.
6) What are your views on conversion and should anti-conversion bill an effective means to curb conversion?
I assume you mean conversion from one religion to another religion. The United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights defines religious conversion as a human right. Article 18 states that everyone has the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion; this right includes freedom to change his religion or belief. It supports voluntary conversion.
One important question that arises to my mind is ‘Why People shed their previous religion voluntarily and adopt a new religion?’ The reasons can be psychological as well as sociological. The religious head should find out an answer for the same and take effective steps to prevent such voluntary conversion. Effective steps can be anything innovative that makes the religion following convenient and comfortable.
There is Forced conversion also. No one should be forced against their will to convert. No national or international law supports forced conversion. I am against the use of forced religious conversions as evidence to support religion. I cannot predict how effective anti-conversion bill will be in curbing such conversions. It is better to wait and see.
i am a resident & voter of bangalore North
Shashi Ji, I request you to support me and encourage your friends and neighborhood to support me. Please visit http://www.nehaaspatil.org for more details and ways to help me out in my campaign.
D/Nehaaji,
I am supporting your campain on FB, we need people from constituencies all over India to follow your example. One thing that bothers me is, as an independent candidate, after your success in the elections, would you affiliate to any major political party? if yes then which? if not then, it would be very difficult to work out interests of your electorate, as we have seen that Govt.’s do not take much cognisance of small groups in parliament (evident from proceedings of LS – Lokpal bill).
can you please enlighten us. I sincerely hope you win with a thumping majority, wishing you the very best and shall pray for your noble cause.
Regards
Frazer
Frazer Keswani ji,
As of now, I am seeking support from the people as an individual who has no affiliations with any political party. You concerns are genuine. Not only for our views to be considered in policy formulation but also to face a MP election successfully, I feel the need of a political party backing.
Till date, no political party has approached me to take me in its fold. I am open to join a political party provided its ideology matches my personal beliefs and principles. I am advised to give first preference to a national party, second preference to a regional party, and third preference to contest as an independent.
As of now, I have decided to continue with my campaign to garner support to my candidature. I hope there will be more clarity by the year end. Will let you know thru my campaign page on FB and also thru my website http://www.nehaaspatil.org.
Thank you very much for the best wishes. Your support and yours friends support are crucial for me.
Thank your RC Ji for the wishes and encouraging words.
@Nehaa Ji,
“However there is nothing wrong in utilizing the same when sanctioned by the UN Security Council because such sanction reflects the backing of international community for such a measure.”
“I am for the international sanctions, backed by the UN, on Pakistan in case any act of Pakistan is a threat to peace.”
From your statements, I think you are a die hard UN aficianado.
One Question for you:
What will be your response if UN SC ‘resolves’ to gift ‘Cash mere’ to Pukistan?
regds
S Ji,
Thank you for the query. The real intention behind my such statement is India should have good international relations. For your query, though I am not an international, I could find out from my team member that Chapter V of the Charter of United Nations which defines powers and functions of security council does not permit UN SC to do what you stated.
Please correct me if I am wrong. To conclude, These Q’s and my answers in any way do not relate to my desire to be a MP from Bangalore North. The people of my constituency are more interested in getting basic problems solved. I intend to work in that direction as their representative. Your guidance in this regard is highly appreciable.
@Nehaa ji,
1) “I could find out from my team member that Chapter V of the Charter of United Nations which defines powers and functions of security council does not permit UN SC to do what you stated”
Can you please make it clear under which article of Chap.V of the Charter of UN ‘prevents’ such actions from UN.
2) As an elected LS member, you may have to ‘vote’ on these kind of issues as well. This kind of ‘die hard’ UN love can cause problems to our nation then.
3)My questions should be not seen as an attempt in discrediting you in any way. My best wishes for your campaign.
regds
S Ji,
For your query (1), you can have a look at Article 24,25, and 26.
For your query (2), I am aware of it and my stand will be directed by people of my constituency. I have created a segment connected to my email group in my website http://www.nehaaspatil.org just to seek my constituency people’s views and shape my thinking that suits the people. I am willing to change my thoughts and tune it to suit the thoughts of my constituency people.
For your query (3), People are not unique in their thoughts and have different views. I respect your views. Thank you very much for the wishes.
Nice to go through the contents Madam.
Infact I got some more clarity on few issues .. Thanks
Madhava Reddy Ji, Welcome.