A Response to Suriya’s “Open Letter to Shantanu”

Dear Suriya,

First of all, thank you for your kind words of support, encouragement and hope. Although I had read your open letter a few days ago, I waited a while because I wanted to post a thoughtful response rather than rushing into a perfunctory acknowledgment.

Let me assure you that you are not alone in your principles and intentions. On this blog alone, you will find several like-minded, kindred souls…No doubt there are many many more out there…

The challenge is to organise, unite and take up this task together…On our own, we will almost certainly fail..Together, we have more than a fighting chance. As you wrote, we need “…the power of a united voice” and agreement on certain “core issues”.

Some of what you are suggesting is already happening…There is an increasing number amongst us who are using RTI laws to make their representatives and local officials accountable…We need more of this.

I would not worry too much about print media…Although it will remain important for many more years to come, long-term trends are not in its favour…There will come a time (in my opinion) within the next decade or so when print medium in India will begin to suffer the way it is beginning to suffer in the west (declining revenues and readership)…So while it is important that our voices/concerns are heard, we need not rely in newspapers now..we can leverage technology to do that.

I completely support you when you write, “I want members to bring up issues and incidents that need others’ attention”…This blog is an attempt at making this happen…and I would be very happy to support any other effort in this direction…There have been some experiments in India with citizens media..but to really make it work, I believe one needs a team of at least 4-5 committed people…otherwise it is unlikely to take off.

I agree when you say, “It is imperative that like minded groups and individuals unite.”…This is precisely the sentiment behind the Hope Summit that I have previously talked about. I have already begun some work to make this happen. In the next few days, I will post a request here asking for some volunteers to help me in this initiative.

One other idea which I am exploring is to have regular tele-conferences on matters/topics of current interest where a lot of people can come together and share their thoughts. Thanks to technology, the cost of doing and managing this is minimal – all it needs is someone with zeal and patience.

Believe me when I say that I am equally concerned as you are with the increasing fragmentation that we see around us…It does not help matters at all…What we need in these times is statesmanship…sadly I dont see that any of that amongst our leadership today. That does not mean all is lost…A beginning has been made…

From one, we are now two…Someday we will be four..and that is how it will grow…The important thing is not to loose sight of the main goal – a proud, resurgent Bharat/India where each one of us – regardless of religion, caste, region, sex has the opportunity to be the best we can. That is my dream…I hope you share that.

Jai Hind, Jai Bharat!
Shantanu

Related Posts:

Changing India – Step I 

Changing India – One Step at a Time 

B Shantanu

Political Activist, Blogger, Advisor to start-ups, Seed investor. One time VC and ex-Diplomat. Failed mushroom farmer; ex Radio Jockey. Currently involved in Reclaiming India - One Step at a Time.

You may also like...

3 Responses

  1. Dear Shantanu

    I like the idea of a Hope Summit, but do you think itself the title should become more focused, or possibly a suitable sub-title found? I’m sure you have thought through these issues, but here are a few of my thoughts for what they are worth.

    People differ dramatically in their world-views and their hopes are different. Hope can be be interpreted or misinterpreted by everyone to suit their taste.

    Some people may well hope for socialism, some may hope to destroy property rights and equalise wealth. Some people may hope that the government should fund them from cradle to grave. Some others may hope for utopias where people are perfect and everything works to their personal liking. Some may hope for a Ram Rajya where their version of Hinduism prevails!

    Inviting everyone who ‘hopes’ for a greater India may lead to chaos and break up the effort since not everyone’s hopes can be or should be fulfilled through joint social action.

    Could the flavour of the search for freedom and integrity be woven into the title? Or a mission statement devised for the proposed summit? Freedom is the core business of a government and the reason why a nation exists. Not charity, not religious aggrandisation, not favourtism of any sort towards anyone. Equal freedom with equal opportunity – that ‘mantra’ is critical to any society’s success. ‘Hope for Liberty’ summit? ‘Liberty for All’ summit? ‘Freedom Summit’?

    Inviting people those who hope for greater freedom, greater equality of opportunity and the consequential integrity in governance and society would lead to a more productive outcome, and advance the focused effort underway with the Freedom Team (freedomteam.in) to create a party or group of candidates who will deliver integrity and good policy. I’d love to find this summit endorse the work of FTI and for its invitees to join the team as leaders. (noting that no one need change their existing party or effort to join this team which is an alliance of leaders, not a party at the moment).

    Anyway, these are surely things you have considered. I keenly look forward to further development of this summit.

    Regards
    Sanjeev

  2. B Shantanu says:

    Sanjeev: Excellent points…You are right that the title may lead to confusion (and worse, chaos).

    I need to think about that…I liked the idea if weaving freedom into the title…and it certainly needs to be on the agenda…

    These are early days on the project…I am trying to find some sponsors for this (and a few people have expressed tentative interest).

    Lot more needs to happen before it can become a reality…so, inputs, comemnts and suggestions are very welcome.

    More on this in the days to come.

  3. Suriya says:

    Thank you for your response. Took me a while to get to this: http://mssnlayam.livejournal.com/16596.html