De-Hinduisation of Kalakshetra?

Please see this images below (courtesy Radha Rajan-ji)..No comment is needed, I think.

This image shows the logo and the letter-head of the Kalakshetra Foundation once upon a time; notice the images of Ganapati and Sanskrit verse

…this subsequently morphed into…

..and finally to what you see below; shorn of all “non-secular” imagery…

**

And in case you are wondering why does this matter (courtesy, Radha Rajan; emphasis added)..

…(these violate) something fundamental to classicism – the essential Hinduness, particularly the bhakti that inspired classicism and inspires continuing adherence to the tenets of classicism in our Sanskrit and Tamil literature and classicism in our arts and performing arts – Carnatic Music, Bharatanatyam, Kucchipudi, Odissi, Mohiniyattam and Manipuri – bhakti or worship.

The building of our temples and the sculptures enriching them are also infused with classicism and therefore infused with bhakti. It follows therefore that if one has to understand Carnatic Music, our classical dance forms, our temples and temple architecture and sculpture, either with a sense of creativity or intellectually, the person must understand bhakti – not superficially and not as a practioner of the abrahamic faiths, but as a Hindu; the person may be an Indian or a non-Indian Hindu but he or she must be infused with bhakti and respect for bhakti to understand classicism.

I have to be worshipful if I have to express the classicism inherent in our performing arts and in our classical literature.

An irreverend mind which is incapable of worship or bhakti, can only produce sterile and soulless creations of Hindu themes. Classicism is also God-centric and does not touch upon human themes except as bhaktas. …The objective of classicism is to elevate the Hindu mind to God through bhakti.

…Bharatanatyam rooted in Bharatamuni’s natyasastra, was preserved in our temples by our devadasis. Hindus owe our devadais a great debt of gratitude that notwithstanding their difficult lives, they nurtured and preserved this great art form. And because this was nurtured by our devadasis and because this was performed in our temples, bharatanatyam and the music that gave it its soul and rhythm retained its bhakti and religious fervor even in difficult times.

Adi Sankara realised the dangers of emphasising abstraction over worship of murtis and ascetism over sringara (the worship and celebration of the beautiful) in advaita and that is why he composed the saundarya lahiri. that is why he sang of Sarada and Annapurna and Shiva. Abstraction is breathtaking but murti worship is elevating. Abstraction is best reached through bhakti and not through the intellect.

…The Besant School started and run by George Arundale and the KFI school started by J Krishnamurti also with Theosophist roots all suffer from the same malaise – the abstraction and eventual erasing of hinduness in their thinking, the institutions they create, their writings and their speech. They are not anti-Hindu in the beginning; they are merely the abstract expression of theosophy and perhaps Buddhism and even some esoteric aspects of Hinduism. But they eventually become anti-Hindu because they partner the explicitly anti-Hindus and non-Hindus and despise those who are angered by the gradual de-hinduisation of their understanding and interpretation of Hindu arts, literature and texts.

It is this perversion which has given rise to Yoga is not Hindu, Meditation is not Hindu, Om is not Hindu, Ayurveda is not Hindu and now Bharatanatyam is not “swaroopa” Hindu but “aroopa” Hindu. It is also the beginning of Deepavali is secular, Navaratri is secular, Pongal is secular and other idiocies. They want the Hindu frills without the Hindu content.

Leela Samson when she stated that she only removed the ‘swarupa’ symbols of hinduism from Kalakshetra in the true spirit of Rukmini Devi’s theosophist spirit, was speaking the truth and the whole truth. The abstraction and diminishing of worship of Hindu Murtis began in Rukmini Devi’s mind. You see this in the children coming out of Krishnamurti schools, you see it in the composition of students learning the performing arts in kalakshetra now under Leela Samson. what Jiddu krishnamurti spoke was the essence of Vedanta and he invoked the enquiring mind so typical of the best methods of Hindu learning in our Guru-Shishya Parampara and gurukulams of our rishis but he disdained to call his thoughts or its articulation Hindu.

…Hindus must know and understand the causes for their degeneration if they have to put these people in their places.
It is not enough to wear the Mayilkann Veshti and Angavastram when you sing an ode to Leela Samson, it is not enough to wear elegant silk and diamond earrings as expressions of refined Brahminical culture when you express disdain for Brahmins and all that they represented, it is not enough to wear long thin red bindi like the Srivasihnava women simply as a fashion statement if your heart does not melt when you worship that Murti. If you cannot bring tears to my eyes when you dance or sing you have to be reborn again and again and again if you have to attain the fulness of MS Subbalakshmi or Palaghat Raghu.

P.S. I wonder how many of you know that Leela Samson at one point headed three important bodies – all at the same time – where the appointing authority is the central government..Kalakshetra, Censor Board of India and Sangeet Natak Academy. Is it really so hard to find capable women and men for these positions?

Related Posts: Baba Ramdev goes politically correct, the missing “H-word” and the ridiculous extremes of pseudo-secularism;

B Shantanu

Political Activist, Blogger, Advisor to start-ups, Seed investor. One time VC and ex-Diplomat. Failed mushroom farmer; ex Radio Jockey. Currently involved in Reclaiming India - One Step at a Time.

You may also like...

11 Responses

  1. S says:

    “Leela Samson when she stated that she only removed the ‘swarupa’ symbols of hinduism from Kalakshetra in the true spirit of Rukmini Devi’s theosophist spirit, was speaking the truth and the whole truth. The abstraction and diminishing of worship of Hindu Murtis began in Rukmini Devi’s mind”

    Is this correct ( rukmini devi’s mind)?

    “Her response against “idol worship” contradicts her mentor and the institution’s founder, Rukmini Arundale, who had defended the Hindu worship of various deities’ images:

    All the songs we dance to are of Gods and Goddesses. You may ask, “Why so many Gods and Goddesses? The only reply I can give is, “Why not so many Gods and Goddess?[6]
    Rukmini did not support a vague notion of a “universal religion” and in fact specifically critiqued this sort of generic spirituality, saying:

    Some people say ‘I believe in universal religion’, but when I ask them whether they know anything about Hinduism, they answer in negative. They know nothing about Christianity, nor about Buddhism or about any other religion either. In other words, universality is, knowing nothing of anything….Real internationalism is truly the emergence of the best in each….But in India when I say India I mean the India of the sages and saints who gave the country its keynote, there arose the ideal of one life, and of the divinity that lives in all creatures; not merely in humanity.[7]”
    (http://christianizingbharatanatyam.blogspot.com/2011/09/educating-rathna-kumar-about-leela.html)

  2. seadog4227 says:

    Aiming for anything less than a Hindu Rashtra will not work, and this has been clear for at least 5 decades now.

  3. Shantanu ji you just highlighted what was going on all our minds for years now, we are witnessing the slow & steady erosion of values, in the name of modern/forward thinking. What the English educated/Left leaning folk do not realize is that they will create a void in society.
    A strong Hindu Rashtra, with patasala system can assure this society and our culture to reclaim our values & system. Hope we start it soon.
    Jai Bharat ….Vande Mataram

  4. K.Harapriya says:

    This attempt to divorce Hindu art from its Hindu roots is unfortunately gaining popularity among some prominent carnatic musicians as well. Radha Rajan is abosolutely correct in pointing out that those who go to J. Krishnamurthy foundation schools often spout such nonsense. Foremost among the young musicians who have a disdain for the bhakthi tradition and claim that carnatic music need not have bhakthi as central to is TM Krishna, who himself is a product of the J. Krishnamurti foundation school. Incidentally he was one of the artists vociferous in insisting on the reinstatement of Leela.

    As an performing artist who is appalled at the attempt to remove Hindu Gods from Hindu art and who strongly believes that without Hinduism these art forms will be like a body without life, I would like to say that those who think that Hindu Gods do not matter, should stop performing music and dance to the compositions of Thyagaraja, Papanasam Sivan etc. and start composing songs on secular themes and see what kind of an audience they get.

  5. Malavika says:

    Some of the supporters of Leela Samson claim that she is being ‘innovative, modern’ etc. However there is no evidence of her innovation. If you remove her contribution i,e removing Hindu symbols like Ganesha and Nataraja there is nothing that separates her from other Bharata natyam dancers.

    And de Hinduizing Bharatanatyam is a sinister move, no wonder she has some powerful backers like N.Ram(a Hindu baiter), Owner of Hindu.

  6. K.Harapriya says:

    I wonder if Hindu groups have any legal recourse to prevent the process of their practices and symbols from being usurped by members of other religions. Is there some kind of public interest litigation that Hindus can undertake to prevent their religious and cultural practises from being removed of its hindu content and grafted on to other religions?

  7. I think what is happening to Kalakshetra or Kurukshetra if you will has to be seen in the context of the social and political changes sweeping across India. There was a time not that long ago when undert the iron fist of the Dravidian Movement brahmins and brahmanical icons were derided in the name of “rationality”. Now under a more inclusive social ambience everyone wants to adopt brhamnical culture without the bagage of religion in wother words like Christianity which took elite Greaco -Roman culture and fashioned it into the European culture of today, brhaminical culture is getting mainstreamed and in gods good time will becoam the dominant cuture of India. So instead of bemoaning the erosion of Hinduism I rather you celebrate it can India cannot be India without its rich heritage.

  8. malavika says:

    @Bahu virupaksha,

    There are several factual errors in your post. Bharatanatyam is not a ‘Brahmanical tradition’, actually it was a temple dance performed by non-brahmins. And because of its pan Hindu appeal it has been adopted enthusiastically by all sub groups/jatis in the South.

    We Hindus know well that the Christians stole Easter, Winter solstice and then genocide d Pagans culturally and physically. There is nothing to be be proud of when our spirituality, yoga, and art forms are bowdlerized and then incorporated into a predatory faith like Christianity. This is nothing but cultural arson.

    There is this distinct trend here, caste is a Hindu problem even though it is equally prevalent in Indian Christians and Muslims. But Hindu contributions like Yoga, Meditation, Bharatanatyam are not Hindu but Universal. However human rights, democracy etc are gift of western civilization!

    It is unbelievable the amount of pretzel logic a lot of Christians and some born Hindus like Deepak Chopra indulge in to De link Hinduism from Yoga and spirituality(meditation, philosophy) from Hinduism. Leela Samson was doing the same thing, de Hinduizing Bharatanatyam. This is sinister.

  9. sushi jhunjhunwala says:

    Some people are of the opinion that an excess of Bhakti brings emotions which are difficult to control. All these symbools bring Bhakti in one’s mind furthering the emotional aspects. This is also true that when you are learning something you should control your emotions and use discrimination more often. But while working you can use particular emotions make them empower you to achieve what you have set yourself to do. I believe these symbols must have helped Rukmini Arundale enhance her emotions and achieved in Kalakshetra what she wanted to do.
    Removing these symbols whether are bringing up better students and results are yet to be seen. Hope Kalakshetra administrators will be able to throw more light on it. Quantity and quality do matter.

  10. v.c.krishnan says:

    Dear All,
    I suggest that all of you invest in the book Bring different by Rajiv Malhotra and it will take you on the path of understanding that we are different and all this Mumbo Jumbo of the Newer sects of India that all religions lead to God is a lot of Bunkum.
    I would also suggest that you read the book Breaking India which will give the schematic things that are taking place all over the world to BREAK INDIA.
    To begin with the Mizo Church has advocated that Mizoram is a Christian State and hence there should not be any Football being played on that day of Sabbath.
    CAN THAT INDIAN GOVERNMENT PERMIT A HINDU STATE? Will the SECULAR PRESS keep quite even if there is dream of a poor farmer in a corner of a remote village in Hassan. We will have it denounced as Militant Hinduism!
    What action is the so called secular press and the secular individuals who permitted MFH to portray Hindu Gods as sexual objects for this. Where is our famous Home Minister!
    Regards,
    vck