Home » Debates & Discussions, World History

Radical Islam, Byzantine and the Huns – Reading Edward Luttwack

14 September 2010 413 views 7 Comments

Thought-provoking and Insightful. Excerpts from Scholar says West should treat radical Islam the way Byzantine generals did the Huns:

*** Excerpts Begin ***

…”The Romans had fought approximately 80 different foes in the process of [their] imperial expansion,” Luttwak said from Washington this week, on the eve of attending the Creative Innovation conference in Melbourne. “And then came one more: the Huns. They had such superior weapons, such superior agility on the battlefield and rapid mobility across vast spaces . . . The Romans were completely outclassed.”

But the Byzantines in their surviving Eastern Roman Empire figured out how to manage the Huns with skilful intelligence gathering and wily diplomacy.

The best historical sources on Attila the Hun are still those intelligence reports, Luttwak says. “Intelligence in the broadest sense. Not just counting how many spears the enemy has but knowing where he’s from, how he dresses, what he eats, what frightens him, what he hopes for.

“Intelligence blinded by ideology cannot see. . . . You need to have an open mind and you need to have the freedom to call a spade a spade. They did and we can’t.”

Edward Luttwack

Image Courtesy: The Australian

Luttwak’s scholarship is contested and his politically incorrect views may leave readers gasping. But there’s something about his logic: in a jam, you don’t want an idealist covering your back but a hard-nosed pragmatist.

The most obvious spade we can’t name is Islam. We pussyfoot around motives for going to war. And we lack the intellectual curiosity that fuels serious intelligence gathering.

…It’s not a matter of resources, he says, but philosophy. The Byzantine empire went to war as a last resort, but when they did, they went with superior forces, not with cannon fodder, and with concrete goals: to preserve the tax-paying lands of empire and defend the Orthodox faith. Our philosophy, by contrast, is ideological.

“Why are we in Afghanistan? To bring democracy?” Luttwak asks rhetorically. “The US is spending $US7 billion [$7.7bn] a month doing things like funding the Afghan parliament. What has a frigging parliament got to do with Afghanistan? All the generals and statesmen who make these wars are slaves of words and concepts. The Byzantines fought for real things, not to save this or liberate that. Their soldiers were skilled craftsmen of war, and you cannot be skilled craftsman of war if you are an 18-year-old boy.”

…He says the Rwandan genocide could easily have been stopped if the world had had the will.

“All you had to do was fly in 3000 European troops,” he says. “Not UN troops in their baby-blue berets standing around watching while the massacres take place. Combat troops, and you tell them to kill any Hutus they see carrying machetes. And Sudan — which is a cardboard government with a cardboard army and jellybaby influence — has killed at least 200,000 people in Darfur. But nobody has gone in, knocked off the Sudanese, and stopped it cold.”

Which brings us to Luttwak’s view of Islam. He pays no lip service to the idea of Islam as a religion of peace: it has been militaristic from the outset.

“We are actually fighting Islam exactly as the Muslims say we are, but we pretend we are not,” he says. “If you take Islam out of the picture in Afghanistan, who would you be fighting? Politically, militarily, or culturally, absolutely nobody.”

What we have created in Afghanistan, he says, is a cargo cult. “All you have to do, if you have a really tin-pot no-good nuisance country, is get a few men together, get them to wear long beards and go round saying death to everybody, and next thing you know the Americans will come and build schools and hospitals for you. And they will give you lots of money so you can build all the villas that are going up in Kabul and stash money in Swiss banks.”

The reality, he says, is that we ought to be fighting Islamism. “But we should be doing it Byzantine way: by staying out of their territory, securing our own and leaving them to fight each other. Instead of going in to your neighbour’s garden to straighten up his weeds, look to your own garden.”

*** End of Excerpts ***

Related Posts:

Why the “War Against Terror” cannot be won by guns alone

“Learning to Live With Radical Islam” – Excerpts

7 Comments »

  • 1. Sid said:

    Read this one before. One more sensible voice in wilderness. But he forgot something. He should have mentioned the state of Byzantine defense, political climate and diplomacy at least a century before the fall of Constantinople. Because such situations carry excellent comparison with the states of western Europe today: financial instability, ideological confusion, complacency, weaker military power (barring Germany) etc. It would make more sense to the eyes that need to read this.

  • 2. Malavika said:

    “The reality, he says, is that we ought to be fighting Islamism. “But we should be doing it Byzantine way: by staying out of their territory, securing our own and leaving them to fight each other. Instead of going in to your neighbour’s garden to straighten up his weeds, look to your own garden.”

    Luttwack forgot the most important issue which is OIL.

    US and Western foreign policy since oil was discovered has been to ensure steady supply of cheap oil. So, a Manhattan Project to find viable alternatives to oil will cut off funding to much of Jihad.

    Let the Arab countries worry about feeding their population without oil.

  • 3. Dinesh Dharme said:

    @Malavika : I agree with you
    Here is Ron Paul, US Republican Senator confirming that fact.
    http://www.lewrockwell.com/paul/paul303.html

  • 4. Dinesh Dharme said:

    A much better video

  • 5. repo man said:

    Yes well this whole oil-funding-islamic-terrorism-and-demographic-invasions business is something well known. But no one has the guts to go and get elected (in any country) on a platform of “saudi arabia are funding the islamic quest for lebensraum and world hegemony” because it would never pass with the mainstream, politically correct media. Why, they’d be torn to shreds. Ol’ mitt may have called it out but he didn’t get elected.
    And in 2012 there are going to be even more muslims and left leaning hispanics in the US, which will make it harder for conservative candidates to get elected with any policies designed to stem so called “stealth jihad”. Its already happened in india; the demographic invasion seems to have done its job, I mean seriously BJP, who are they……..?
    But its not to late to turn the tide if people are made aware of the facts, I don’t mean giving them frothing-at-the-mouth rants like this. Just give them the facts about how saud is known to spend its oil money…….

  • 6. Indrani Deb said:

    thankyou for this article, this gave me a forward thought and i am learning how to link history with current facts.

  • 7. Martin Dalsace said:

    When talking about Byzantine, look up:

    1. the story of the catalan company, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catalan_Company and

    2. the story of the almogavars, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Almogavars

    as it seems, they were very effective against the invading turcs.

    3. and of their leader, who was a german, rutger de blum, known as roger de flor http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roger_de_Flor

    to my knowledge, they have been in history of christian-islamic clashes the most efficient way pushing back invading islam.

Share your thoughts below.

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Share your opinions responsibly. Stay on topic. Please note that by posting a comment, you indicate consent to the terms and conditions of this site. First-timers, please read the comments policy here

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.