Comments on: Vande Mataram – Expose the Mullah’s specious argument http://satyameva-jayate.org/2006/08/30/vande-mataram-expose-the-mullahs-specious-argument/ Dedicated to "Bharat" and "Dharma" Tue, 22 May 2012 14:46:30 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.1.3 By: Shoaib http://satyameva-jayate.org/2006/08/30/vande-mataram-expose-the-mullahs-specious-argument/comment-page-1/#comment-239397 Shoaib Mon, 10 Oct 2011 10:20:17 +0000 https://hindudharma.wordpress.com/2006/08/30/vande-mataram-expose-the-mullahs-specious-argument/#comment-239397 I liked ur article. Islam teaches to love ones country.vande this word is derived from sanskrit according to hindu(sanatan)religion every thing is god & from Islamic point of view everything is god's we muslims will not be muslim even we think to worship other than ALLAH.vande means worship,salutation when a Muslim sing by keeping the first meaning in mind then we've the problem if with 2nd meaning then we dont have problem.You know Muslims sing national anthem Jana gana from years even in madrasas(religious schools) but the main point is there is it important to make it national song when it is in praise of beloved motherland not about the nation so most of the muslims r going to oppose it by knowing this fact politicians wants to play with this contraversial issue just for the votes though we r having 2 different opinion so its better choose the 1one u can reply me on given email id ok bye I liked ur article. Islam teaches to love ones country.vande this word is derived from sanskrit according to hindu(sanatan)religion every thing is god & from Islamic point of view everything is god’s we muslims will not be muslim even we think to worship other than ALLAH.vande means worship,salutation when a Muslim sing by keeping the first meaning in mind then we’ve the problem if with 2nd meaning then we dont have problem.You know Muslims sing national anthem Jana gana from years even in madrasas(religious schools) but the main point is there is it important to make it national song when it is in praise of beloved motherland not about the nation so most of the muslims r going to oppose it by knowing this fact politicians wants to play with this contraversial issue just for the votes though we r having 2 different opinion so its better choose the 1one u can reply me on given email id ok bye

]]> By: Indian http://satyameva-jayate.org/2006/08/30/vande-mataram-expose-the-mullahs-specious-argument/comment-page-1/#comment-20765 Indian Thu, 29 Jan 2009 18:22:48 +0000 https://hindudharma.wordpress.com/2006/08/30/vande-mataram-expose-the-mullahs-specious-argument/#comment-20765 Law of the land in use. Did any one hear that word "Haram" and "Sinful". And see the trick to change that haram in to non haram. I knew they will touch the ear not from the front but from the back. My message: Even in all that silent postures Hindu god resides. Believe me!. Stop doing it completely also in the name of sports or exercise. That will be best exercise for all of you. Right! It is also forbidden for muslim to vote for a non-muslim candidate leader. Now what is left? Law of the land in use.

Did any one hear that word “Haram” and “Sinful”. And see the trick to change that haram in to non haram.
I knew they will touch the ear not from the front but from the back. My message: Even in all that silent postures Hindu god resides. Believe me!. Stop doing it completely also in the name of sports or exercise. That will be best exercise for all of you. Right!

It is also forbidden for muslim to vote for a non-muslim candidate leader. Now what is left?

]]> By: Indian http://satyameva-jayate.org/2006/08/30/vande-mataram-expose-the-mullahs-specious-argument/comment-page-1/#comment-20763 Indian Thu, 29 Jan 2009 18:05:30 +0000 https://hindudharma.wordpress.com/2006/08/30/vande-mataram-expose-the-mullahs-specious-argument/#comment-20763 Source: http://www.medindia.net/news/view_main_print_new.asp“>www.medindia.net JAKARTA, INDONESIA, January 27, 2009: Muslims in Indonesia have been banned from doing yoga if they engage in Hindu religious rituals during the exercise. About 700 clerics from the Indonesian Council of Ulemas (MUI) agreed on that action at a national meeting on Sunday. “The yoga practice that contains religious rituals of Hinduism including the recitation of mantras is ‘haram’ (forbidden in Islam),” according to chariman Ma’ruf Amin. “Muslims should not practise other religious rituals as it will erode and weaken their Islamic faith.” Indonesian Muslims are still allowed to do yoga strictly as exercise. “If it is purely a physical exercise or sport, it is not considered as ‘haram,’” Amin said. The clerics also banned Indonesian Muslims from abstaining from voting, as the country gets ready for April’s election. “As long as there is a candidate leader that meets criteria such as being Muslim, honest, brilliant and ready to fight for Indonesian people’s aspirations, it is ‘haram’ for Muslims to abstain from voting,” Amin said. But he added: “It is forbidden for Muslims to vote for a non-Muslim candidate leader.” Nearly 90 percent of Indonesia’s 234 million people are Muslim. Religious edicts issued by the MUI are not legally binding on Muslims, but it is considered sinful to ignore them. Source: http://www.medindia.net/news/view_main_print_new.asp“>www.medindia.net

JAKARTA, INDONESIA, January 27, 2009: Muslims in Indonesia have been banned from doing yoga if they engage in Hindu religious rituals during the exercise. About 700 clerics from the Indonesian Council of Ulemas (MUI) agreed on that action at a national meeting on Sunday.

“The yoga practice that contains religious rituals of Hinduism including the recitation of mantras is ‘haram’ (forbidden in Islam),” according to chariman Ma’ruf Amin. “Muslims should not practise other religious rituals as it will erode and weaken their Islamic faith.” Indonesian Muslims are still allowed to do yoga strictly as exercise. “If it is purely a physical exercise or sport, it is not considered as ‘haram,’” Amin said.

The clerics also banned Indonesian Muslims from abstaining from voting, as the country gets ready for April’s election. “As long as there is a candidate leader that meets criteria such as being Muslim, honest, brilliant and ready to fight for Indonesian people’s aspirations, it is ‘haram’ for Muslims to abstain from voting,” Amin said. But he added: “It is forbidden for Muslims to vote for a non-Muslim candidate leader.”

Nearly 90 percent of Indonesia’s 234 million people are Muslim. Religious edicts issued by the MUI are not legally binding on Muslims, but it is considered sinful to ignore them.

]]> By: B Shantanu http://satyameva-jayate.org/2006/08/30/vande-mataram-expose-the-mullahs-specious-argument/comment-page-1/#comment-20694 B Shantanu Wed, 28 Jan 2009 07:02:28 +0000 https://hindudharma.wordpress.com/2006/08/30/vande-mataram-expose-the-mullahs-specious-argument/#comment-20694 For those who would like to re-ignite the debate, three separate links below: http://www.satyashodh.com/vandemataram.htm http://indianmuslims.in/and-what-is-my-issue-with-vande-mataram/ http://www.frontlineonnet.com/fl1601/16010940.htm I need to dig deeper...More on this, hoepfully soon. For those who would like to re-ignite the debate, three separate links below:

http://www.satyashodh.com/vandemataram.htm

http://indianmuslims.in/and-what-is-my-issue-with-vande-mataram/

http://www.frontlineonnet.com/fl1601/16010940.htm

I need to dig deeper…More on this, hoepfully soon.

]]> By: Indian http://satyameva-jayate.org/2006/08/30/vande-mataram-expose-the-mullahs-specious-argument/comment-page-1/#comment-20674 Indian Tue, 27 Jan 2009 21:51:19 +0000 https://hindudharma.wordpress.com/2006/08/30/vande-mataram-expose-the-mullahs-specious-argument/#comment-20674 @Salman It doesnot matter how you reach your ear, just fold your hand and touch it or take your hand around back of your neck and touch the ear. One and the same. Why make complex? @Salman

It doesnot matter how you reach your ear, just fold your hand and touch it or take your hand around back of your neck and touch the ear. One and the same. Why make complex?

]]>